{
  "prefix": {
    "pe": "https://proofengine.info/proofs/the-climate-has-always-changed-today-s-warming-is/",
    "prov": "http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#",
    "xsd": "http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#",
    "schema": "http://schema.org/"
  },
  "entity": {
    "pe:claim": {
      "prov:type": "pe:Claim",
      "prov:label": "The climate has always changed \u2014 today's warming is not unusual or alarming.",
      "prov:value": "The climate has always changed \u2014 today's warming is not unusual or alarming."
    },
    "pe:evidence-B1": {
      "prov:type": "pe:EmpiricalEvidence",
      "prov:label": "SC1: NASA \u2014 paleoclimate evidence of past changes",
      "pe:factId": "B1",
      "pe:evidenceType": "empirical",
      "pe:sourceUrl": "https://science.nasa.gov/climate-change/evidence/",
      "pe:sourceName": "NASA Science \u2014 Climate Change Evidence"
    },
    "pe:evidence-B2": {
      "prov:type": "pe:EmpiricalEvidence",
      "prov:label": "SC1: NOAA \u2014 historical temperature record",
      "pe:factId": "B2",
      "pe:evidenceType": "empirical",
      "pe:sourceUrl": "https://www.climate.gov/news-features/understanding-climate/climate-change-global-temperature",
      "pe:sourceName": "NOAA Climate.gov \u2014 Climate Change: Global Temperature"
    },
    "pe:evidence-B3": {
      "prov:type": "pe:EmpiricalEvidence",
      "prov:label": "SC2: NASA \u2014 10x faster than ice age recovery",
      "pe:factId": "B3",
      "pe:evidenceType": "empirical",
      "pe:sourceUrl": "https://science.nasa.gov/climate-change/evidence/",
      "pe:sourceName": "NASA Science \u2014 Climate Change Evidence"
    },
    "pe:evidence-B4": {
      "prov:type": "pe:EmpiricalEvidence",
      "prov:label": "SC2: IPCC AR6 \u2014 unprecedented in 2000 years",
      "pe:factId": "B4",
      "pe:evidenceType": "empirical",
      "pe:sourceUrl": "https://www.carbonbrief.org/in-depth-qa-the-ipccs-sixth-assessment-report-on-climate-science/",
      "pe:sourceName": "IPCC AR6 via Carbon Brief"
    },
    "pe:evidence-B5": {
      "prov:type": "pe:EmpiricalEvidence",
      "prov:label": "SC2: NOAA \u2014 0.20\u00b0C/decade since 1975",
      "pe:factId": "B5",
      "pe:evidenceType": "empirical",
      "pe:sourceUrl": "https://www.climate.gov/news-features/understanding-climate/climate-change-global-temperature",
      "pe:sourceName": "NOAA Climate.gov \u2014 Climate Change: Global Temperature"
    },
    "pe:evidence-B6": {
      "prov:type": "pe:EmpiricalEvidence",
      "prov:label": "SC2: U of Arizona \u2014 unprecedented in 24,000 years",
      "pe:factId": "B6",
      "pe:evidenceType": "empirical",
      "pe:sourceUrl": "https://news.arizona.edu/news/global-temperatures-over-last-24000-years-show-todays-warming-unprecedented",
      "pe:sourceName": "University of Arizona News \u2014 Kaufman et al. study"
    },
    "pe:evidence-A1": {
      "prov:type": "pe:ComputedEvidence",
      "prov:label": "SC1 verified source count",
      "pe:factId": "A1",
      "pe:evidenceType": "computed",
      "pe:method": "count(verified citations for SC1) = 2",
      "pe:result": "2"
    },
    "pe:evidence-A2": {
      "prov:type": "pe:ComputedEvidence",
      "prov:label": "SC2 verified source count (disproof)",
      "pe:factId": "A2",
      "pe:evidenceType": "computed",
      "pe:method": "count(verified citations for SC2 disproof) = 3",
      "pe:result": "3"
    },
    "pe:verdict": {
      "prov:type": "pe:Verdict",
      "prov:label": "Verdict: PARTIALLY VERIFIED",
      "prov:value": "PARTIALLY VERIFIED"
    }
  },
  "activity": {
    "pe:verify-B1": {
      "prov:type": "pe:CitationVerification",
      "prov:label": "Verify B1: NASA Science \u2014 Climate Change Evidence",
      "pe:status": "verified",
      "pe:method": "full_quote",
      "pe:fetchMode": "live"
    },
    "pe:verify-B2": {
      "prov:type": "pe:CitationVerification",
      "prov:label": "Verify B2: NOAA Climate.gov \u2014 Climate Change: Global Temperature",
      "pe:status": "verified",
      "pe:method": "full_quote",
      "pe:fetchMode": "live"
    },
    "pe:verify-B3": {
      "prov:type": "pe:CitationVerification",
      "prov:label": "Verify B3: NASA Science \u2014 Climate Change Evidence",
      "pe:status": "verified",
      "pe:method": "full_quote",
      "pe:fetchMode": "live"
    },
    "pe:verify-B4": {
      "prov:type": "pe:CitationVerification",
      "prov:label": "Verify B4: IPCC AR6 via Carbon Brief",
      "pe:status": "verified",
      "pe:method": "full_quote",
      "pe:fetchMode": "live"
    },
    "pe:verify-B5": {
      "prov:type": "pe:CitationVerification",
      "prov:label": "Verify B5: NOAA Climate.gov \u2014 Climate Change: Global Temperature",
      "pe:status": "not_found",
      "pe:method": null,
      "pe:fetchMode": "live"
    },
    "pe:verify-B6": {
      "prov:type": "pe:CitationVerification",
      "prov:label": "Verify B6: University of Arizona News \u2014 Kaufman et al. study",
      "pe:status": "verified",
      "pe:method": "full_quote",
      "pe:fetchMode": "live"
    },
    "pe:determine-verdict": {
      "prov:type": "pe:VerdictDetermination",
      "prov:label": "Determine verdict from evidence",
      "prov:endTime": "2026-03-29"
    }
  },
  "agent": {
    "pe:proof-engine": {
      "prov:type": "prov:SoftwareAgent",
      "prov:label": "Proof Engine",
      "schema:version": "1.2.0",
      "schema:url": "https://github.com/yaniv-golan/proof-engine"
    }
  },
  "wasGeneratedBy": {
    "pe:gen-B1": {
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B1",
      "prov:activity": "pe:verify-B1"
    },
    "pe:gen-B2": {
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B2",
      "prov:activity": "pe:verify-B2"
    },
    "pe:gen-B3": {
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B3",
      "prov:activity": "pe:verify-B3"
    },
    "pe:gen-B4": {
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B4",
      "prov:activity": "pe:verify-B4"
    },
    "pe:gen-B5": {
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B5",
      "prov:activity": "pe:verify-B5"
    },
    "pe:gen-B6": {
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B6",
      "prov:activity": "pe:verify-B6"
    },
    "pe:gen-verdict": {
      "prov:entity": "pe:verdict",
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict"
    }
  },
  "wasDerivedFrom": {},
  "wasAttributedTo": {
    "pe:attr-verdict": {
      "prov:entity": "pe:verdict",
      "prov:agent": "pe:proof-engine"
    }
  },
  "used": {
    "pe:used-B1": {
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict",
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B1"
    },
    "pe:used-B2": {
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict",
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B2"
    },
    "pe:used-B3": {
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict",
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B3"
    },
    "pe:used-B4": {
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict",
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B4"
    },
    "pe:used-B5": {
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict",
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B5"
    },
    "pe:used-B6": {
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict",
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B6"
    },
    "pe:used-A1": {
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict",
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-A1"
    },
    "pe:used-A2": {
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict",
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-A2"
    }
  }
}