{
  "prefix": {
    "pe": "https://proofengine.info/proofs/topaz-et-al-2026-analyzed-2-5-million-biomedical-papers-in-pubmed-central-from/",
    "prov": "http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#",
    "xsd": "http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#",
    "schema": "http://schema.org/"
  },
  "entity": {
    "pe:claim": {
      "prov:type": "pe:Claim",
      "prov:label": "Topaz et al. (2026) analyzed 2.5 million biomedical papers in PubMed Central from January 2023 through February 2026 and identified 4,046 references pointing to studies that do not exist, distributed across 2,810 papers.",
      "prov:value": "Topaz et al. (2026) analyzed 2.5 million biomedical papers in PubMed Central from January 2023 through February 2026 and identified 4,046 references pointing to studies that do not exist, distributed across 2,810 papers."
    },
    "pe:evidence-B1": {
      "prov:type": "pe:EmpiricalEvidence",
      "prov:label": "SC1: corpus size from Topaz et al. 2026 methods",
      "pe:factId": "B1",
      "pe:evidenceType": "empirical",
      "pe:sourceUrl": "https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(26)00603-3/fulltext",
      "pe:sourceName": "Topaz M, Roguin N, Gupta P, Zhang Z, Peltonen L-M. Fabricated citations: an audit across 2\u00b75 million biomedical papers. Lancet 2026; 407: 1779-81."
    },
    "pe:evidence-B2": {
      "prov:type": "pe:EmpiricalEvidence",
      "prov:label": "SC2: date range from Topaz et al. 2026 methods",
      "pe:factId": "B2",
      "pe:evidenceType": "empirical",
      "pe:sourceUrl": "https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(26)00603-3/fulltext",
      "pe:sourceName": "Topaz M, Roguin N, Gupta P, Zhang Z, Peltonen L-M. Fabricated citations: an audit across 2\u00b75 million biomedical papers. Lancet 2026; 407: 1779-81."
    },
    "pe:evidence-B3": {
      "prov:type": "pe:EmpiricalEvidence",
      "prov:label": "SC3: 4046 fabricated references (Topaz et al. 2026 results)",
      "pe:factId": "B3",
      "pe:evidenceType": "empirical",
      "pe:sourceUrl": "https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(26)00603-3/fulltext",
      "pe:sourceName": "Topaz M, Roguin N, Gupta P, Zhang Z, Peltonen L-M. Fabricated citations: an audit across 2\u00b75 million biomedical papers. Lancet 2026; 407: 1779-81."
    },
    "pe:evidence-B4": {
      "prov:type": "pe:EmpiricalEvidence",
      "prov:label": "SC4: 2810 affected papers (Topaz et al. 2026 limitations)",
      "pe:factId": "B4",
      "pe:evidenceType": "empirical",
      "pe:sourceUrl": "https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(26)00603-3/fulltext",
      "pe:sourceName": "Topaz M, Roguin N, Gupta P, Zhang Z, Peltonen L-M. Fabricated citations: an audit across 2\u00b75 million biomedical papers. Lancet 2026; 407: 1779-81."
    },
    "pe:evidence-A1": {
      "prov:type": "pe:ComputedEvidence",
      "prov:label": "SC1 verified-source count",
      "pe:factId": "A1",
      "pe:evidenceType": "computed",
      "pe:method": "count(verified sc1 citations) = 1",
      "pe:result": "1"
    },
    "pe:evidence-A2": {
      "prov:type": "pe:ComputedEvidence",
      "prov:label": "SC2 verified-source count",
      "pe:factId": "A2",
      "pe:evidenceType": "computed",
      "pe:method": "count(verified sc2 citations) = 1",
      "pe:result": "1"
    },
    "pe:evidence-A3": {
      "prov:type": "pe:ComputedEvidence",
      "prov:label": "SC3 verified-source count",
      "pe:factId": "A3",
      "pe:evidenceType": "computed",
      "pe:method": "count(verified sc3 citations) = 1",
      "pe:result": "1"
    },
    "pe:evidence-A4": {
      "prov:type": "pe:ComputedEvidence",
      "prov:label": "SC4 verified-source count",
      "pe:factId": "A4",
      "pe:evidenceType": "computed",
      "pe:method": "count(verified sc4 citations) = 1",
      "pe:result": "1"
    },
    "pe:verdict": {
      "prov:type": "pe:Verdict",
      "prov:label": "Verdict: PROVED",
      "prov:value": "PROVED",
      "pe:doi": "10.5281/zenodo.20306620"
    }
  },
  "activity": {
    "pe:verify-B1": {
      "prov:type": "pe:CitationVerification",
      "prov:label": "Verify B1: Topaz M, Roguin N, Gupta P, Zhang Z, Peltonen L-M. Fabricated citations: an audit across 2\u00b75 million biomedical papers. Lancet 2026; 407: 1779-81.",
      "pe:status": "verified",
      "pe:method": "full_quote",
      "pe:fetchMode": "snapshot"
    },
    "pe:verify-B2": {
      "prov:type": "pe:CitationVerification",
      "prov:label": "Verify B2: Topaz M, Roguin N, Gupta P, Zhang Z, Peltonen L-M. Fabricated citations: an audit across 2\u00b75 million biomedical papers. Lancet 2026; 407: 1779-81.",
      "pe:status": "verified",
      "pe:method": "full_quote",
      "pe:fetchMode": "snapshot"
    },
    "pe:verify-B3": {
      "prov:type": "pe:CitationVerification",
      "prov:label": "Verify B3: Topaz M, Roguin N, Gupta P, Zhang Z, Peltonen L-M. Fabricated citations: an audit across 2\u00b75 million biomedical papers. Lancet 2026; 407: 1779-81.",
      "pe:status": "verified",
      "pe:method": "full_quote",
      "pe:fetchMode": "snapshot"
    },
    "pe:verify-B4": {
      "prov:type": "pe:CitationVerification",
      "prov:label": "Verify B4: Topaz M, Roguin N, Gupta P, Zhang Z, Peltonen L-M. Fabricated citations: an audit across 2\u00b75 million biomedical papers. Lancet 2026; 407: 1779-81.",
      "pe:status": "verified",
      "pe:method": "full_quote",
      "pe:fetchMode": "live"
    },
    "pe:determine-verdict": {
      "prov:type": "pe:VerdictDetermination",
      "prov:label": "Determine verdict from evidence",
      "prov:endTime": "2026-05-20"
    }
  },
  "agent": {
    "pe:proof-engine": {
      "prov:type": "prov:SoftwareAgent",
      "prov:label": "Proof Engine",
      "schema:version": "1.34.0",
      "schema:url": "https://github.com/yaniv-golan/proof-engine"
    }
  },
  "wasGeneratedBy": {
    "pe:gen-B1": {
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B1",
      "prov:activity": "pe:verify-B1"
    },
    "pe:gen-B2": {
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B2",
      "prov:activity": "pe:verify-B2"
    },
    "pe:gen-B3": {
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B3",
      "prov:activity": "pe:verify-B3"
    },
    "pe:gen-B4": {
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B4",
      "prov:activity": "pe:verify-B4"
    },
    "pe:gen-verdict": {
      "prov:entity": "pe:verdict",
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict"
    }
  },
  "wasDerivedFrom": {
    "pe:deriv-A1-from-B1": {
      "prov:generatedEntity": "pe:evidence-A1",
      "prov:usedEntity": "pe:evidence-B1"
    },
    "pe:deriv-A2-from-B2": {
      "prov:generatedEntity": "pe:evidence-A2",
      "prov:usedEntity": "pe:evidence-B2"
    },
    "pe:deriv-A3-from-B3": {
      "prov:generatedEntity": "pe:evidence-A3",
      "prov:usedEntity": "pe:evidence-B3"
    },
    "pe:deriv-A4-from-B4": {
      "prov:generatedEntity": "pe:evidence-A4",
      "prov:usedEntity": "pe:evidence-B4"
    }
  },
  "wasAttributedTo": {
    "pe:attr-verdict": {
      "prov:entity": "pe:verdict",
      "prov:agent": "pe:proof-engine"
    }
  },
  "used": {
    "pe:used-B1": {
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict",
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B1"
    },
    "pe:used-B2": {
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict",
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B2"
    },
    "pe:used-B3": {
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict",
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B3"
    },
    "pe:used-B4": {
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict",
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-B4"
    },
    "pe:used-A1": {
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict",
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-A1"
    },
    "pe:used-A2": {
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict",
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-A2"
    },
    "pe:used-A3": {
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict",
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-A3"
    },
    "pe:used-A4": {
      "prov:activity": "pe:determine-verdict",
      "prov:entity": "pe:evidence-A4"
    }
  }
}